What business are you in?

If I asked you what business you are in, what would you say?  Consulting, retail, manufacture, accounting, health...Well you're wrong, kind of. You see I think you are in the business of behavioural change because everyday you are influencing people to do something.  Buy, sell, read, write, talk, type, click, swipe, walk, run, turn up.  Each of us everyday has the task of influencing others to move from one state to another, and that's why behavioural economics is such an opportunity; it's a playbook on what you need to do.


Lessons from the fitness industry
Let's take some guidance then from one of the most challenging behavioural changes that we can make - getting ourselves or others into shape. The difficulty has always been sustaining the change once initial enthusiasm has worn off, and this is due to the potency of the outcome (looking better, feeling better) not being as forceful as the immediate attraction of other choices (lazing on the couch, staying in bed or eating the wrong foods).  After all, you can experience the benefits of the chocolate now, but the benefits of not eating the chocolate are distant and ambiguous. 


Given this challenge it is therefore no surprise that a range of websites and Apps have been developed to help people sustain the behavioural change of a healthier lifestyle.

GymPact App

One that garnered a lot of attention last year was GymPact because it charges you if you don't follow through on your commitment.  The concept is that our desire to avoid a penalty will be enough to push us towards fronting up at the gym when we would otherwise have been able to talk ourselves out of it. The App is clever because it creates activities in the short term to keep us on track as we inch toward to longer term benefit.

Another site that works for any type of personal commitment is StickK. Here you are required to make public your commitment contract and even put money on the line that goes to a recipient of your choice if you fail.  

A more recent example is SlimKicker.  I first heard about the concept last year when it's creator got in touch to discuss how behavioural economics could be incorporated to help keep people motivated and accountable.  


According to SlimKicker developer Christine Chu, the site is designed to maintain motivation and emotional engagement by rewarding and reinforcing progress.

"I think the main problem with being healthy is motivation. It's an abstract, overwhelming goal. I think the best way to counter this is to turn it into winnable games and small victories.

 So... my app makes living healthy, and fitness into a RPG game, where users earn points, and "level up' as they accomplish their health goals.

Everytime they add something healthy like veggies to their diet, they earn points. Everytime they complete a workout, they earn points. As they achieve more and more, they'll level up and unlock badges, and discounts/coupons to  rewards like spas, health foods, etc."

A few of the clever elements of SlimKicker include;

• Levels - people move through different fitness levels, collecting points and rewards along the way which breaks the task of 'getting fit' down to goals that are attainable. (Overcoming behavioural short-term bias.)
• Progress -  Throughout each level the user can see how far they have come and have to go. (Using behavioural principle of completion to secure continuation once started.)
• Inspiration feed - a sense of community has been created through users sharing how they are feeling about their successes and slip ups. (Uses social norming to influence behaviour.)

By far my favourite part of SlimKicker is the Challenges section. You can sign up to participate in challenge (for instance, no snacks after dinner) and be rewarded with points upon completion.  What's great about this is that you can see at a glance "who's in" and how many others are giving the challenge a go.

SlimKicker's Challenge

There are some areas of SlimKicker that can be further improved, for instance showing how many points are needed to complete a level, clearly stating that the website is free to join and explaining
how the site is financially supported but I think they are doing a great job of tackling behavioural change.

Applications for your business
Getting people to exercise and eat healthier is really no different to the challenge of getting people to buy something today when the benefit is not immediate.  Examples include building a house, securing investors for your proposal, ordering something online where you have to await delivery, signing up for a course, contracting a consultant and paying insurance. You need to overcome the pain of now whilst keeping your customer's 'eye on the prize'.

• Make the benefit vivid:  Draw it, mock it up, make a model...do something that ensures the customer can see what they are working towards.
• Use milestones: stage the process so that your customer feels like things are progressing.  Think of it like FedEx parcel tracking where your customer can see how far the parcel has travelled and how far it has to go.
• Keep the connection: communicate with your customer throughout the process so they feel comfortable that things are progressing.  I ordered a new iPhone cover through a Kickstarter project in December last year for expected delivery in January. Today I received project update number 18 advising me where they were up to in production, so whilst it's a long time to wait, I have been taken on their journey throughout thanks to their frequent and transparent communications.

It's easy to think we are  simply in whatever business we spruik on our business card or website, but always remember we are behavioural change experts and it is up to us to support our customers going from one state to another.  What better guide than Behavioural Economics?


PS Why not join the People Patterns mailing list?  Every month you'll receive a short wrap-up of top news from the behavioural sciences and other nuggets of goodness from me. Click here to sign-up.

PPS A short presentation I have put together on why every business should know about behavioural economics is available on this website and has been viewed over 1,200 times since being posted.

"From-To" image from http://www.rachel-levy.com/wp-includes/wp-content/uploads/From_To.jpg

Easter Eggxample of Behavioural Economics

Easter Eggs.  If you're ever chatting with someone who isn't familiar with Behavioural Economics or doesn't see the opportunities in understanding the power of irrationality, Egg them.  Let me explain.

We love Easter Eggs. In Australia we consume an average of twenty Easter Eggs for every man, woman and child, and that means it's big business for our chocolate manufacturers.  But in economic decision making terms, our love of Easter Eggs is irrational.  Here's why.

Imagine you visited two different supermarkets.

• The first offered you 100 grams of Cadbury chocolate for $2.98.
• The second likewise offered you 100 grams of Cadbury chocolate, but for $2.15.

You'd opt for the second, right?  After all, it's the same product but you save almost 40%.

Now imagine you are within one of the supermarkets and they have two offers;

• The first is the same offer you took above, 100 grams of Cadbury chocolate for $2.15.
• The second offer is an Easter Egg. 100 grams of Cadbury for $2.98.

Now which do you choose?

Block chocolate vs Easter Egg

Traditional economics, based on rational arguments of supply and demand would have us taking the $2.15 offer every time.  But guess what? We are not always rational.  The fact that the chocolate is shaped like an egg, wrapped in foil, available at a certain time of year and can be given as a gift means that the majority of us will buy the $2.98 Easter Egg and pay a 40% premium.

And Behavioural Economics can help us explain why. 

Relativity

We make judgments about one thing relative to another.  In the examples above, 100g of chocolate that was the same could be judge of the basis of price.  However, when one chocolate was shaped like an egg, the grounds of relativity became different.  Have you ever wondered why Easter Eggs are not in the confectionery aisle?  Because relativity is being confined to the "Easter Egg"  category rather than the chocolate category. (And for anyone who may argue that it would be logistically difficult to have the Eggs in the chocolate aisle I will posit that if Eggs were shown to sell better in the aisle, that 'logistical difficulty' argument would evaporate. It's purely about moving higher margin chocolate, and that is best done when the customer can't easily compare $2.98 to $2.15.)

Social Influence
We are greatly influenced by others around us.  Indeed, that we even have such things as Easter Eggs is a social construct.  To give your child a block of chocolate is just not the same as an Egg.  As consumers we justify the economic irrationality by deferring to such emotional reasons as the magic of an Easter Egg hunt, smiles on faces etc.  And as marketers, that's what we aim to amplify so that our Brands have a reason to be purchased outside purely rational reasons.

And this is a key thing about explaining Behavioural Economics.  All those reasons for paying more can be cited by the consumer as entirely rational because we are great at justifying our decisions. But rationalised isn't the same as economically rational.  Why is this important?  When you next pitch a product or campaign for development, remember it's not just about the 100 grams of chocolate. It's the shiny foil, the social construct, the timing, the gifting, the emotion that your customer will be processing when they are in your aisle.  Get excited because if you can help your consumer rationalise their purchase, the economic rationalisation becomes moot.

And this is the massive opportunity Behavioural Economics presents to marketers, product managers and retailers.  Yours is the opportunity to turn the magic of irrationality into margin for your business.  So tell me, what's your Egg? 

Prices quoted from Woolworths, Moorabbin 8 April 2011